Design of the canned anchoveta supply chain to raise its consumption and reduce hunger and malnutrition among children, adolescents, and pregnant mothers in Peru

Design of the canned anchoveta supply chain to raise its consumption and reduce hunger and malnutrition among children, adolescents, and pregnant mothers in Peru

Design of the canned anchoveta supply chain to raise its consumption and reduce hunger and malnutrition among children, adolescents, and pregnant mothers in Peru

Background

Peru is the largest exporter of animal protein. Peru holds the most abundant fishery resource in the world: the Peruvian anchoveta. However, we Peruvians have not yet rationalized its use in the fight against hunger and malnutrition.

This confirms the paradox that says:

Peru is the largest exporter of animal protein, yet its own population lives with hunger and malnutrition.

The problem

The quality of canned anchoveta produced in Peru is deficient. This shortfall stems from failing to meet basic food-quality requirements. This lack of quality reduces consumer interest in the domestic market. Peruvian anchoveta is recognized as the best available animal protein. Its high nutritional value makes it a primary, year-round food source. The quality shortfall in canned anchoveta stems from process and procedure nonconformities throughout the value-adding sequence. The problem becomes more serious when nonconformities occur at the CCPs (critical control points), which carry the highest risk in the process flow.

The problem could be stated thus:

Canned anchoveta could be consumed on a massive scale at every socioeconomic level in the country, if the nonconformities that prevent compliance with the food-quality requirements demanded by international standards are eliminated.

Nonconformities identified

Observed on the artisanal boats that fish anchoveta for direct human consumption (CHD)

Observed in canning plants that can anchoveta for direct human consumption (CHD)

  • Use of non-selective fishing nets on a single boat that both catches and collects.
  • Deficient lifting and bulk loading of the catch into the catch boat’s hold.
  • Loss of catch quality from bulk loading into the catch boat’s hold.
  • No effective method for preserving catch quality.
  • Deficient method of unloading the catch at the landing pier.
  • Deficient method of transporting the catch from the pier to the canning plant.
  • Ineffectiveness of quality control throughout the fish-canning process.
  • Cross-contamination with fishmeal production processes.
  • Absence of an effective quality-management system in the process flow.

Corrective actions defined

Applicable to artisanal boats that fish anchoveta for direct human consumption (CHD)

Applicable in canning plants that can process anchoveta for direct human consumption (CHD)

  • Design of the operation for the pair-fishing system (two boats).
  • Design a selective fishing net for capturing anchoveta.
  • Design of the process of setting and hauling the net on the Catch Boat.
  • Design the catch-preservation system (cold chain).
  • Design of the process of lifting the catch onto the Collection Boat.
  • Design of the process of stowing the catch on the Collection Boat.
  • Design of the process of landing the catch at the pier.
  • Design of the process of resupplying the boats at the pier.
  • Design of the process of transporting the catch from the pier to the plant.
  • Design of labels and metal packaging exclusive to the project.
  • Implement FAO best practices for handling the catch.
  • Implementation of the ISO 9001, 14001, and 45001 quality standards.
  • Implement and certify to the ISO 22001:2018 food safety standard.

Proposed solution

  1. The project team has carried out root-cause analysis for each identified nonconformity. The RCA conclusions enabled us to define corrective actions to be implemented in the value-adding sequence. The project will obtain international food-quality certification under the ISO 22001:2018 standard and official FDA FSVP (Foreign Supplier Verification Program) registration, in conformity with FSMA.

  2. Construction of the canned anchoveta supply chain, which will be made up of four direct participants who will be called, invited, selected, and chosen by the project team:

    • The vessel owner of an artisanal boat that currently operates in the anchoveta fishery for direct human consumption (CHD).
    • The owner of a 70- to 75-foot vessel withdrawn from the industrial fishery.
    • The owner of an operating fish cannery, a small or medium-sized enterprise.
    • The owner of a metal-packaging factory, a small or medium-sized enterprise.
  3. The four participants participate in project management decision-making. A strategic alliance under the joint-venture model will link them. Benefits will be distributed in direct proportion to the contribution to the direct cost of producing the product.

  4. The supply chain will prioritize increasing and consolidating the product’s share of the domestic market. It will design and conduct a strategy to promote consumption of the canned anchoveta product. First, through existing distribution channels. Second, it will prioritize creating a new sales network, committed to delivering to the end consumer “a natural, healthy, safe, nutritious, and wholesome food, at a price that everyone will be able to pay.”

The objective

The objective of the project is to contribute in a real, efficient, and effective way to the reduction of hunger, malnutrition, and anemia in the most vulnerable social groups, made up of children of primary-school age, adolescents at secondary level, and pregnant mothers who, because of their condition of poverty, pass on to their unborn children the effects produced by the lack of food.

The project is in essence a model of social and food development. In our case, “model” means “sample” or “working example.” It has been created to be easily replicated. It results from assembling various adaptive innovation applications. It is scalable, replicable, and sustainable; it will use existing assets and infrastructure; it does not require large investments; its implementation and operation do not depend on political decisions; it can be put into operation in a short time; it is extremely friendly to the environment; principles and values of human solidarity inspire it; it will have every segment of our population as consumers; and, finally, it will be a highly profitable business.

The project will operate through an operations-management system that continually improves process and product quality within the value-adding sequence. It will maintain the highest performance standards. The project will implement FAO guidelines for responsible handling of the catch during capture, collection, and transport to the pier.

At the manufacturing stage, the company will apply Codex Alimentarius quality requirements. In addition, the company will obtain international food-quality certification under ISO 22001:2018. Finally, the FDA will obtain FSVP (Foreign Supplier Verification Program) registration, in accordance with FSMA regulations for imported foods consumed in the USA. These certifications will become “seals of quality assurance” for foreign consumers of the project’s products.

Strengths

  1. First strength: the idea behind this project began developing in 2017. The model we applied shares important points with the conceptual basis of the framework published in 2019 by IFAD, titled “Nutrition-Sensitive Value Chains from a Smallholder Perspective: A Framework for Project Design.” Isabel de la Peña, James Garrett, and Aulo Gelli.

    Spanish rendering: “Cadenas de valor sensibles a la nutrición desde una perspectiva de pequeños propietarios: un marco para el diseño de proyectos.” Isabel de la Peña, James Garrett, and Aulo Gelli.

    IFAD summarizes that document as follows:

    In sum, the framework has been validated technically and operationally, and we expect it can be useful for development organizations and governments interested in designing and implementing Value Chain projects that also improve the nutrition of project beneficiaries. From a development and poverty-reduction perspective, a Value Chain approach is an analytical framework for considering the chain as a whole.

    Spanish rendering: “En resumen, el marco ha sido validado técnica y operacionalmente, y nosotros esperamos que pueda ser de utilidad para las organizaciones de desarrollo, como también para los gobiernos que estén interesados en diseñar e implementar proyectos para cadenas de valor que trabajen para mejorar la nutrición de los beneficiarios del proyecto. Desde una perspectiva de desarrollo y reducción de la pobreza, un modelo de cadena de valor es un marco analítico a través del cual se considera a los elementos de la cadena como un todo.”

    A comparative analysis between the project and the framework prepared by IFAD shows that the project best gives material form to the conceptual basis developed in the IFAD framework. However, our research predates IFAD’s.

  2. Second strength: the FSN Forum has accepted our project abstract in the current call. We assume this acceptance reflects the points it shares with the three sets of recommendations that informed the FSN Forum call.

    The three sets of recommendations are:

    1. Inclusion of small stakeholders.
    2. Stakeholder access to the market.
    3. Sustainability of the project.

    Before IFAD’s publication, the project had already considered the concepts set out in the IFAD framework’s three sets of recommendations.

    The first set proposes including smallholders (stakeholders) in value chain formation. The project includes four smallholders: an artisanal fishing vessel owner; a vessel owner whose vessel was withdrawn from the industrial fishery; the owner of a small canning plant in operation; and the owner of a small or medium-sized enterprise that manufactures food metal packaging.

    The second set of recommendations proposes direct market access for the participating smallholders. The project considers forming a joint venture that would allow the four participants to share decision-making for managing the entire chain. Under the joint-venture model, the four participants will also share in the profits.

    The third set of recommendations establishes the condition that the value chain be sustainable as a business. The project rests on the assured availability of anchoveta as raw material. When anchoveta is caught selectively, the anchoveta resource remains available permanently and sustainably. The only limitation on raw material supply to the plant will occur during pre-spawning (gravid) and spawning.

    At the other end of the chain, demand for canned anchoveta, the project’s final product, is expected to increase immediately after consumers appreciate the added value attributes, such as quality, fitness for use, and guaranteed food safety.

  3. Third strength: this is, without any doubt, the most important. Our pre-feasibility study applies technological innovation, supported by current science and technology, and builds on the founding ideas of an earlier project prepared in the 1970s. The original edition of our project was called the Sarveta Project (a combination of the words sardine and anchoveta).

    That project was part of the Comprehensive Fisheries Study (Estudio Integral de la Pesca), prepared by CRC (Corporación de Racionalización y Consultoría). Consulting firms from the United States, Canada, and Europe took part in its preparation, such as Arthur D. Little, Tudor Engineering, ABS (American Bureau of Shipping), Rados Western Corporation, Vickers Hydraulic Equipment, MARCO (Marine Construction) of Seattle, Bluenose Fishing Nets, and Electronic ELAC (Electronic for Acoustic Detection), among many other consulting firms and suppliers of fishing equipment and machinery. The project received technical assistance from Norwegian, Swedish, English, and Irish fishery experts, assigned full-time by the FAO Office in Peru.

    During the validation and assumption-checking stages, the project fitted out a 65-foot metal-hulled vessel, withdrawn from the industrial fishery, to carry out anchoveta capture tests using a selective fishing net. The vessel was named “Sarveta.” Under the direction of FAO fishery experts, they designed and assembled a selective fishing net to capture anchoveta at its maximum size and development.

    The fishing results with the net were validated. The FAO expert who conceived, designed, built, and tested it described it as “an effective tool for selective anchoveta fishing.”

    The Sarveta project was to operate at the La Puntilla Fishing Complex, in Pisco. Against all expectations, the Sarveta Project was abandoned for reasons we do not know. The Sarveta project was never implemented, even though its evaluation recommended it. In 1973, a thesis at the School of Economic Engineering of the UNI demonstrated the project’s full feasibility.

    Our updated version is a systemic model that applies the method proposed in the APICS OMBOK to operations management, centered on supply-chain management and implemented through process management.

    The new version builds on the fundamental scientific and technological research conducted for the original version. The technology has been adapted to improve on the earlier one. The process-flow diagram of this new version has been redesigned and updated to use equipment, tools, and materials of the current technological generation.

    Implementing and operating the project involves no risk. Putting it into operation will mark the beginning of a solution to hunger and malnutrition in the country, along with the relaunch of a national fish-canning industry that will adopt international food quality and food safety standards as mandatory requirements in food production.

Positive impacts

The project will generate disruptive positive impacts across the fishing sector’s productive activities, with greater emphasis on artisanal fisheries and the small- and medium-sized canning industry. The positive impacts of greatest relevance will be seen in the following fields:

  • Scientific: it reorients research on anchoveta as a quality food resource, rather than a quantity one.
  • Technological: it introduces capture and handling methods used in developed countries.
  • Industrial: it relaunches the national canning industry by providing a permanent supply of raw material.
  • Food: it effectively reduces the effects produced by hunger, malnutrition, and childhood anemia.
  • Ethical: it positions anchoveta as a healthy, nutritious food for the population’s benefit.
  • Moral: it directs the anchoveta catch quota assigned to direct human consumption (CHD) to eliminate illegal fishing, or pesca negra (clandestine fishing).
  • Social: it creates permanent jobs and prioritizes women’s employment.
  • Labor: it reduces the randomness of artisanal fishers’ work, making fishing schedulable.
  • Environmental: it restores anchoveta’s natural right to survive, allowing it to grow and reproduce.
  • Academic: it opens new professional specializations in fisheries and food engineering.
  • Economic: the added value of anchoveta makes it profitable, exportable, and a source of foreign exchange.
  • Popular: a 1-kilogram net-weight family-size can of anchoveta will feed five people at an “affordable” price.

Statement of intent

The Lumen Perú research team believes the project objective is clearly expressed. However, we believe we should mention the initial agreements that led us to prepare the project and seek the support needed to implement it.

Initial agreements

  1. First: the project will focus on promoting the rational use of anchoveta as food for people.
  2. Second: the beneficiaries will be vessel owners and artisanal anchoveta fishers for direct human consumption (CHD).
  3. Third: it will include small- and medium-sized canneries and metal-packaging factories as beneficiaries.
  4. Fourth: the beneficiaries will be the business owners and will be allied through a joint venture.
  5. Fifth: once the pre-feasibility study is concluded, the feasibility study will begin immediately.
  6. Sixth: once the feasibility study is concluded and the necessary funds are obtained, the pilot will be implemented by putting the business into practice.
  7. Seventh: operating the pilot will verify the business model’s merits and positive impacts.
  8. Eighth: once the model’s viability has been verified, the joint venture will continue to operate if the owners so decide.
  9. Ninth: Lumen Perú will make the model available to those who decide to replicate it at a larger scale.
  10. Tenth: Lumen Perú will provide consulting to those interested in replicating the model at a larger scale.

 

Secured By miniOrange